Encarta Will Be Discontinued, Does Wikipedia Replace It?

Microsoft announced a few months ago that it will discontinue its Encarta software, including its online resources (MSN-based Web site). The official reason for this operation seems to be that users do not use the traditional way (i.e. a well trusted, official encyclopedia, like Encarta was) to search for information, they instead rely on search engines and resources like the publicly editable Wikipedia online encyclopedia (although Microsoft doesn’t mention it directly I personally feel that’s the one they’re implying).

I know that Wikipedia articles and their content can be discussed/debated and therefore articles are usually accurate, but there are many times when (and I found myself looking at such articles too often):

  • Wikipedia articles aren’t complete (of course sometimes Encarta haven’t even had articles on many topics that Wikipedia has, so this may be considered as an advantage; but it’s really frustrating to read only one paragraph or so regarding something, a paragraph that usually adds nothing to what you already know about the searched topic; it would have been better to just not find anything about it);
  • Wikipedia articles aren’t accurate (Encarta used experts in many areas to make sure their articles are technically and/or scientifically accurate); many times you could get wrong information about some topics you knew everything about, and until the discussion/debate decided about whether it may be too late for somebody else who would simply trust the source without waiting;
  • Wikipedia articles aren’t gramatically correct, or have technical mistakes: many times you can find duplicate paragraphs, incomplete sentences, broken text blocks, or even wrong characters used inside text.

Because of all these, I was hoping that Encarta will NOT die. But unfortunately I cannot do much to help: Microsoft already decided its future and it’s not pink. So let’s move on, and maybe the next good thing is to participate more in Wikipedia (or a different publicly editable encyclopedia), so that articles become as complete, accurate, and correct as possible.

If you were to replace Encarta online with a different (but also free) online encyclopedia, what would be your choice? Would it be Wikipedia or do you have an alternative? Maybe a more trustable one? Thanks in advance for your answer!

Update: It seems Microsoft has decided to keep MSN Encarta Dictionary, tough. (This is based on an e-mail I’ve received on October 7, 2009, from MSN Encarta team.)


About Sorin Dolha

My passion is software development, but I also like physics.
This entry was posted in Computers and Internet. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Encarta Will Be Discontinued, Does Wikipedia Replace It?

  1. Tudor Turcu says:

    As far as I remember, Encarta online was not entirely free (only a part of articles).Anyway, if I will need a good encyclopedia there’s always http://www.britannica.com/

  2. Sorin says:

    Yes, you are right that for some time the MSN Encarta was not 100% free (you had to have a subscription, either Encarta or MSN subscription), but when you used Windows Live search engine you could search within ALL Encarta and view ALL the full articles (initially, by using Windows Live Search you got 2 free hours of ALL MSN Encarta after each search, but since the last year, ALL MSN Encarta was free, even if you didn’t search it through Windows Live). So, in the last couple of years, anyone could access virtually all Encarta articles online, freely. Of course you didn’t get the "special" features of Encarta Premium software such as collages or 3D pictures, but that was (at least for me) not the point anyway.However, thank you for the suggestion of using Britannica. I saw their online articles are a accessible freely (with adverisments), so indeeed, it seems is a nice (and for me more important, trustful) source of information.

  3. LUCY says:

    As a student learning Inglish, Encarta dictionary help me a lot, with information about the meaning of differents word , the pronunciation and fonetic sounds. I will be lost by October 30th, when encarta will be gone.

  4. ron says:

    bob wrote: I going to miss the phonetic sounds!!1 hope you’re right,Please keep "Encarta Dictionary"…!

Add a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s